OSCAR EMR is open source software. Which means you can download, install, and use it for free. For ever.
Richard Stallman, very much the face and voice of the Open Source movement,
is keen to point out that open source means free of restrictions (like free speech) rather than free of cost (ie: not free beer!).
OSCAR software is both, in that you won't pay a cent for the software. However, it does have costs associated with it in terms of time and equipment. These costs will vary enormously depending on where you start from (ie: how much time you have already spent learning how to set up, run, and use computers yourself, and how much equipment you have already purchased).
In this section, we'll look at how those costs vary for different OSCAR installation scenarios.
1. The Zero Cost ScenarioOffice size: single physician office, one receptionist, one nurse. 1500 patients.
Baseline IT: The physician is very IT savvy and knows how to set up and maintain a linux server. She already has a computer set up in her office, the nurse's office, and at the reception desk. All three computers are connected to the internet and each other via a local area network, have a laser printer and a label printer already installed. Her receptionist has used an EMR before in a previous job, and her nurse is quite computer literate.
Installation Plan: The physician decides to use a spare PC that she has at home as the server. It has a large enough hard drive, enough memory (RAM), and a fast enough processor to meet the minimum specifications for running Oscar (as listed in
David Daley's excellent installation how-to). She downloads and installs the (free, open source) Ubuntu operating system on the server and then installs OSCAR (again, following
David's instructions).
She plans to do this, and test the installation over the weekend. She searches online for any information she needs, including a free PDF copy of the OSCAR user manual.
She plans to see the patients in her room mainly, with the computer, and use the two examination rooms (without computers) as needed.
She plans to book no patients for Monday so she can train the staff in the use of OSCAR. She instructs her receptionist to enter the details for the patients for the rest of the week on Monday afternoon, and to enter other patient details as they are booked in. She expects to add one hundred patients per week for the first three months and have almost all patients to be on the system by the end of one year.
Total cost: $0Ongoing costs: $0Note: Although there are opportunity costs to this installation (the lost billings from Monday, losses due to the system being slow while the staff get used to it, and the cost of the receptionist's time as she enters patient demographics into the system) these should be compensated for by efficiency gains very rapidly.
Note 2: Had she not had a spare PC to install OSCAR on, the cost of a PC with the minimum specifications for a small office installation (eg: Dell Inspiron 530s) can be as low as $450 including taxes.
2. The Low Cost ScenarioOffice size: three physician office, two receptionists, two nurses. 4500 patients.
Baseline IT: The physicians are computer literate, but they do not know much about setting up linux servers. They already have computers set up in their clinical rooms, their offices, and at the reception desk. All computers are connected to the internet and each other via a local area network, have access to a laser printer and a label printer (some of them to a central printer). Their receptionists have used a computerized billing and appointment system but not an EMR. The nurses are computer literate.
Installation Plan: The physicians plan to purchase a server with OSCAR pre-installed and to have a local IT expert set it up for them and provide regular support. They have discussed backup options with their IT provider, and have opted for a rotating backup to a series of USB keychains. One of them will store the backup discs securely in a safe at home.
The IT provider arrives as planned, sets up the OSCAR server and connects it to the existing computer network. The physicians close the office for the day to allow the installation and training.
They instructs their receptionists to enter the details for the patients for the rest of the week on Monday afternoon, and to enter other patient details as they are booked in. They expect to add two hundred patients per week for the first three months and have almost all patients to be on the system by the end of one year.
Costs:Hardware: One server with Ubuntu pre-installed with surge protection and battery backup $1400
Time for IT installation and training: 7 hours @ $85/hr = 595
TOTAL SETUP COST: $1995(Cost per physician: $665)
Ongoing Costs: Basic IT support package
$200/monthNote: Again, the opportunity costs should be compensated for by efficiency gains after the first few weeks.
3. The High End ScenarioOffice size: five physician office, four receptionists, one manager, three nurses. 10,000 patients.
Baseline IT: The physicians are computer literate, but they do not know much about setting up linux servers. They share a single, old, computer which has internet access but no printer. The reception has a single, old, computer which has access to a printer but it too is old and in need of replacement. The computers are very slow due to their lack of adequate memory (RAM) and their old processors.
Installation Plan: The physicians discuss their needs with an OSCAR-familar IT specialist who they commission to purchase and install the system.
The specialist recommends that they need to install computers in each of the seven clinical rooms, and that they should purchase a rack server with OSCAR pre-installed. He recommends a separate backup server system.
They plan on installing the computer network first, which should take about two days. It will disrupt the working of the clinic as the system is installed, and will involve a telecom engineer installing CAT5 cables running to each of the rooms.
Once this first phase is completed, the IT specialist installs the servers. This does not disrupt the working of the clinic.
For phase three, a temporary receptionist is hired to relieve the main reception staff who take it in turns to enter demographic details for all 10,000 patients. The IT specialist oversees the reception staff training for this phase. This takes three months.
Finally, the IT specialst returns and trains the staff in the use of the clinical system and a go-live date is picked.
The entire process takes around six months.
Costs:Hardware:
Rack server with Ubuntu pre-installed $4,000
Surge protection and battery backup $1,000
Backup server $2,000
18 workstation computers @ $400/each = $7,200
18 monitors @ $200 each = $3,600
11 small laser printers @ $80 each = $880
11 small label printers @ $250 each = $2,750
1 large laser printer/copier $750
Installation of CAT5 network system (50 connection ports) $2,000
Router box $500
Locking rack cabinet $1,200
IT specialist time ($100/hr) 40 hours = $4,000
3 months full time receptionist cover $7,000
TOTAL SETUP COST: $36,880Cost per physician: $7,376
Ongoing Costs: IT support package $500/month
SummaryAn IT savvy physician with a reasonable IT setup already in place can install and run OSCAR EMR essentially for nothing.
However, offices that have no IT systems (or systems that are so old as to be obsolete) will require significant outlays in harware and installation to provide adequate internet access to their staff and physicians. This is because without near-patient internet access, OSCAR cannot function. This is true of all EMRs.
Caveat! These examples are entirely hypothetical. Although the hardware costs are reasonably accurate at the time of writing, IT support costs can vary dramatically.